• Home
  • About JTO
    • The Apostolic Mission of Journey To Orthodoxy
    • Support JTO
    • What Others Are Saying
    • Speaking
  • You’re On with Fr. John
  • Orthodox Faith
    • Scripture in the Liturgy
    • Orthodoxy Explained [VIDEO]
    • How To Become An Orthodox Christian
    • Finding The New Testament Church
  • Q & A
  • Webmaster Resources
  • DONATE
    • Needs
  • Contact

Journey To Orthodoxy

The 'Welcome Home' Network

  • Clergy
  • Revert Stories
  • Other Christians
    • Roman Catholics
      • Byzantine Catholics
    • Anglicans/Episcopalians
    • Lutherans
    • Mainline Protestants
      • Calvinist/Reformed
      • Christian Scientists
      • Methodist/Wesleyan
      • Plymouth Brethren
      • Quaker
      • Amish
    • Evangelicals
    • Baptists
    • Pentecostals
    • Women converting without their husbands
    • Men converting without their wives
  • Other Monotheists
    • Jews
    • Muslims
    • Jehovahs Witnesses
    • Rastafarians
  • Non-theists
    • Agnostics
    • Atheists
    • Buddhists
  • Polytheists
    • Mormons/LDS
    • Hindus
    • Pagans
    • Wiccans
  • Mass Conversions
    • Parish Conversions

Can a Protestant Evangelical find a home in Orthodoxy?

December 1, 2018 By Fr. John 10 Comments

One Man’s Journey Home

by Dave Bugbee

Can a Protestant Evangelical find a home in Orthodoxy? Can a Westerner with no Russian, Greek, Romanian or Arabic background find a home in Orthodoxy? Is this a chasm too wide to be crossed? These were the questions I would seek to answer.

I was raised in a nominally Protestant home and made a commitment to faith in Jesus Christ when I was a college student. I became a devoted Evangelical Protestant. For many years, I was active in Protestant churches, serving in a variety of capacities, as pastor, Bible teacher, youth leader and volunteer youth worker. I had deep fellowship with numerous committed believers and took my spiritual journey and spiritual struggle very seriously.

The years passed. I moved from the East Coast to Colorado and became involved in churches in Colorado. Over time, however, I became restless. I was looking for more depth in my faith, longed for worship not compromised by pop culture, and sought deep roots.

During my travels, I noticed a church with a gold dome. From its appearance, I knew the church to be Orthodox. I knew little about Orthodoxy. I had long been fascinated by Russia and had the vague notion that there was a deep well of spirituality in Russia. But that’s about as much as I knew. One day, I visited that church with the gold dome. If the church seemed to be a “cult,” I would not return. But if I felt at home there, I wanted to explore further. Some Evangelicals were moving in a direction of cultural accommodation that I did not want to go. I was looking for a new church home.

That visit to the church with the gold dome went well. Yes, it was very different in format but I saw and heard nothing to scare me off. To this Evangelical Protestant, the beliefs and words I heard sounded “orthodox.” Nothing sounded heretical or scary.

RELATED   Georgian Women, Doctors to Build Church as Repentance for Abortions

I resolved that I would take my time. I was not going to rush into anything. I contacted the parish priest of that church to ask for some book recommendations. I was not looking for polemics, I was looking for spiritual nourishment. The books recommended were food for the soul. One of them, in particular, was life-changing.

During subsequent visits, my question became, “Could I in good conscience, as an Evangelical, find a home in Orthodoxy? Were there deal-breakers that would drive me off?”

Certainly there were differences. But I found that the core essentials were the same. Committed believers, whether Evangelical or Orthodox, ultimately sought the same goal: REALITY WITH GOD. I found that the worship in which I participated, the conversations I had, the books I read, connected with the same God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ that I had sought, followed, and known for years.

The decision came slowly and gradually. But the day came when I was ready. I “came home” to Orthodoxy.

I had found a new church home.

Source

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Email
  • Print

Related Posts

Filed Under: Evangelicals, Latest Stories

Need an Orthodox Catechism?

Comments

  1. Renata says

    December 2, 2018 at 5:57 pm

    I wonder if you could mention the books which were recommended, particularly the one you thought life-changing. Thank you.

  2. Danielia says

    December 2, 2018 at 11:10 pm

    I’ve had a similar conversion. Orthodoxy is a deep well, and I hope to draw from it for a long time.

  3. Rosalind Hamilton says

    December 5, 2018 at 8:49 am

    I too, would love to know the titles of the books that had such a positive effect.

    Lindy Hamilton

  4. Fr. John says

    December 5, 2018 at 10:26 pm

    You may wish to contact him at the Source link at the bottom of the article.

  5. Barbara Phillips says

    December 7, 2018 at 10:12 am

    I noticed as I am covering from Protestant to Orthodox. Many Orthodox believers think ALL Protestants are the same…and I declare they are NOT.

  6. Fr. John says

    December 8, 2018 at 4:06 pm

    Many cradle Orthodox do believe that, but we who are converts know better.

  7. Jo says

    January 8, 2019 at 12:25 pm

    I am on a similiar Journey. Could you tell me what books you read.

  8. Fr. John says

    January 9, 2019 at 10:29 am

    Jo, the best thing to do is reach out to your local Orthodox priest and parish. They have a multitude of resources.

  9. Jo says

    January 9, 2019 at 10:42 am

    What books were read that for him were life changing. As someone asked earlier in comments

  10. Fr. John says

    January 9, 2019 at 10:46 am

    You will have to contact him at the source link and ask him directly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 



 

Courses for YOU!

Courses in Orthodox Theology priced for YOU






Recent Updates and Blogposts

  • Mass Baptisms Around the World at Theophany
  • Belfast parish baptizes 10+ in Irish Sea
  • Orthodox Liturgy celebrated in ancient Welsh church for first time since Great Schism

The Deep Dark Archives

Find what you’re looking for

Copyright © 2025 Fr. John A. Peck · Journey to Orthodoxy · All Rights Reserved
Designed by Fr. John A. Peck